Summary
- British Columbia has a strategy for electrifying its ferries by using hybrid battery-electric power plants.
- Norway has a larger ferry network than British Columbia, but has wasted time and money on hydrogen-powered ferries.
- BC Ferries has opted for a strategy using batteries and biofuels as a path forward for decarbonization.
- Hydrogen has been proven to be inefficient, expensive, and environmentally harmful in maritime transportation.
- BC Ferries is showing Norway what to do by avoiding hydrogen and focusing on batteries and biofuels for its ferry fleet.
Article
British Columbia and Norway both have extensive ferry networks, with BC Ferries operating a fleet of vessels serving 47 destinations along the province’s coastline, and Norway operating around 180 ferries across 112 routes. BC Ferries has a strategy for its ferries that involves diesel-battery hybrid power plants and compatibility with biodiesel, while Norway has several electrified ferries in operation. BC Ferries is gradually moving towards fully electric ferries, acknowledging the challenges of infrastructure and cost associated with electrification.
BC Ferries has ruled out using liquid natural gas (LNG) for its ferries due to high emissions, cost, and environmental concerns. The focus is on battery-electric and biofuels as the most viable options for achieving zero emissions in the future. Norway, on the other hand, has invested time and resources in hydrogen-powered ferries, which have faced challenges such as high costs, inefficiency, and technical barriers. BC’s approach of avoiding hydrogen for its ferry fleet highlights the importance of focusing on solutions that are practical, cost-effective, and sustainable.
Hydrogen has been touted as a potential alternative fuel for maritime transportation, but its drawbacks include high emissions during production, leakage issues, high costs, and inefficiency compared to direct electricity usage. BC’s decision to dismiss hydrogen for its ferries aligns with the global trend of moving away from hydrogen as a transportation fuel due to its environmental impact and economic feasibility. Norway’s experiences with hydrogen-powered ferries further highlight the challenges associated with this technology.
BC Ferries is focusing on a hybrid battery-electric and biofuel strategy for its ferries, aiming to reduce emissions immediately while preparing for a transition to fully electric vessels in the future. By avoiding the distractions of hydrogen technology, BC is able to make progress towards decarbonizing its fleet in a more efficient and cost-effective manner. Other ferry operators globally should take note of BC’s approach and consider similar strategies for achieving sustainability in their operations.
Ferry terminals can benefit from solar installations and battery storage to support electrification efforts, but the challenge lies in upgrading the grid infrastructure to support larger electric ferries. BC Ferries’ commitment to a gradual shift towards fully electric ferries reflects a pragmatic approach that acknowledges the need for incremental progress while addressing operational challenges. By focusing on a combination of battery-electric and biofuel technologies, BC is taking the right steps towards decarbonizing its ferry fleet and leading by example for other operators.
As a resident of BC, the author appreciates BC Ferries’ strategic approach to decarbonization, which prioritizes practical solutions over potentially unsustainable technologies like hydrogen. Norway’s experiences with hydrogen-powered ferries serve as a cautionary tale, highlighting the importance of investing in solutions that are environmentally friendly, economically viable, and technically feasible. BC’s leadership in embracing electrification for its ferry fleet sets a positive example for the industry and underscores the importance of making informed decisions based on real-world experience and data.
Read the full article here
